Is this OTT?

Off-topic chat. Items cannot be returned without a ticket.

Is this OTT?

Postby Assmask » 14th Apr 09, 02:30

Here is a song I'm about to demo to my band (just finished it now) - however I'm having some doubts.

http://www.myspace.com/runningsoloonempty

Is the piano too much? It would mean drafting in a new band member to play it, but I think keyboard in a rock band has a lot of merit.

I think the biggest area of doubt is the whole instrumental section after the first chorus; it's quite heavy and out of place. But that actually endears me to it.

You, as paragons of great taste, erdution and discernment, are requested to offer your advice and opinion for this tune. It's 6:20 long - should I reduce that by removing a minute or two of riffing? Or does it work quite well as it is?

If you can spare a few minutes from your hectic sechedules, some feedback would be appreciated on this one.
Assmask
 
Posts: 571
Joined: 30th Mar 06, 12:22
Location: Belfast

Postby spoon_of_grimbo » 15th Apr 09, 00:20

that was pretty fucking awesome mate! it definitely didn't feel like it was that long, which is a good thing as it shows it doesn't drag at all. one or two transitions seemed a bit wobbly (like when the heavy guitars hit, and the sudden transition back to just quiet guitar and voice at the end), but those are pretty small complaints really. and i really enjoyed the huge riffy bit, definitely keep that!

as for the piano, i thought it was reasonably subtle, but if your bandmates aren't cool with adding another member just for that, i reckon the piano could be more of a studio thing; it's definitely effective, but the song would still stand up pretty well live without it, or with a clean guitar playing that part.
IF THERE'S A SOUND YOU PLAY THAT DOESN'T FIT TODAY,
WHY NOT JUST PLAY THE BASTARD ANYWAY?!
Image
spoon_of_grimbo
 
Posts: 915
Joined: 19th Aug 07, 13:56
Location: Boston, UK (Home) / Coventry, UK (Uni)

Postby spoon_of_grimbo » 15th Apr 09, 00:29

actually, having given that a second listen, scratch my comments about the wobbly transitions, they actually work really well!

also i have two questions:

1. would you be so kind as to let me have an mp3 of "only naomie"?
2. i can't wait to hear the finished full-band recorded version of this.
3 (since 2 wasn't really a question). do you want me to play this on my internet radio show? cuz i quite happily would. we get like, 20 listeners max, but it's better'n nothing :lol:
IF THERE'S A SOUND YOU PLAY THAT DOESN'T FIT TODAY,
WHY NOT JUST PLAY THE BASTARD ANYWAY?!
Image
spoon_of_grimbo
 
Posts: 915
Joined: 19th Aug 07, 13:56
Location: Boston, UK (Home) / Coventry, UK (Uni)

Postby Assmask » 15th Apr 09, 03:13

I'm happy that you liked it! I posted it on another forum and the comment there was that the middle section was a but unnecessary, however I did think that riff heavy bit would find more sympathy on a WH forum than anywhere else!

I think I'd still like to make it a bit more compact and make the instrumental more relevant, but I'd be happy to give you an MP3 of it as it is now if you'd prefer. There are a couple of bum notes in it which I'd have to re-record but that's not hard.

I should also write some more lyrics so I don't keep repeating the verse! If you were to play this opn your show I'd like to tidy it up a lot first, but I'm happy enough to do that, naturally!

Thanks for your enthusiasm :)
Assmask
 
Posts: 571
Joined: 30th Mar 06, 12:22
Location: Belfast

Postby markE » 15th Apr 09, 11:19

the intro is very, very nice.
the quiet bits remind me of jimmy eat world and the rifferama is wildheartsish - so a combo of two of my favourite bands. i think with a bit of polish this could be a real corker. well done.
the piano is not too much - sounds v good.
why do i have to ignore you to get your attention?
markE
 
Posts: 764
Joined: 18th May 06, 13:53

Postby Assmask » 20th May 09, 15:24

OK, for those of you who commented (thanks!), I have amended the song!

www.myspace.com/runningsoloonempty

I have removed all piano bits - not because I don't like them, just because we don't have a pianist in the band! I might add some piano for my own pleasure at some point, but right now I am after somethign raw. The song is over a minute shorter, and I don't see any way of bringing that down further.

It's the first one by the way, Only Naomie.
Assmask
 
Posts: 571
Joined: 30th Mar 06, 12:22
Location: Belfast

Postby spoon_of_grimbo » 20th May 09, 20:20

that's pretty fuckin badass mate! not sure why i didn't notice before, but in some parts you sound very much like dave from soul asylum in your vocal style!
IF THERE'S A SOUND YOU PLAY THAT DOESN'T FIT TODAY,
WHY NOT JUST PLAY THE BASTARD ANYWAY?!
Image
spoon_of_grimbo
 
Posts: 915
Joined: 19th Aug 07, 13:56
Location: Boston, UK (Home) / Coventry, UK (Uni)

Postby Assmask » 20th May 09, 22:22

Cheers - I've not really heard them. I'll have a listen. I think my vox is my Achilles heel, so if I hear someone making money out of it who is similar to me that can only be encouraging!
Assmask
 
Posts: 571
Joined: 30th Mar 06, 12:22
Location: Belfast

Postby Benny Hiroshima » 20th May 09, 23:27

Nice, intro of Only Naomi reminds me a bit of Do Anything mixed with The Only Ones "Another Girl Another Planet"

I'd say don't be afraid to hold back on the vocals though - feel like you're holding back a bit.

On the whole, very good, love the riffs too!
Image
Benny Hiroshima
 
Posts: 24
Joined: 16th May 09, 02:11
Location: Cardiff / Swansea

Postby Assmask » 21st May 09, 11:50

Cheers Benny - get your point about the vox holding back. I get a bit self conscious in my house, walls are thin, neighbours are in etc etc. But my voice does sound better if I really let loose. I only do that on rare occasions however, unless at a practise of course.

OK, we're booked into the studio a week this Saturday, going to lay down all the drum tracks professionally, then I'm going to do the guitar, bass and vox myself at home - Well, the band will play their bits, but I'll be doing the mixing and all of that.

Might bring back the piano for a special OTT version. I like OTT.
Assmask
 
Posts: 571
Joined: 30th Mar 06, 12:22
Location: Belfast

Postby spoon_of_grimbo » 21st May 09, 13:29

if you REALLY wanna go OTT, throw in a harmonized dual guitar solo, and have 4-part vocal harmonies.

and a gong!



but seriously, can't wait to hear the final version mate!
IF THERE'S A SOUND YOU PLAY THAT DOESN'T FIT TODAY,
WHY NOT JUST PLAY THE BASTARD ANYWAY?!
Image
spoon_of_grimbo
 
Posts: 915
Joined: 19th Aug 07, 13:56
Location: Boston, UK (Home) / Coventry, UK (Uni)


Return to The Cloakroom

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests