Chewin' a piece of your Custard Pie

Off-topic chat. Items cannot be returned without a ticket.

Chewin' a piece of your Custard Pie

Postby VladDracii » 20th Oct 08, 16:40

Does anyone else share my view that Physical Graffiti by Led Zeppelin is the finest work they've done?

All I ever hear about is people going on about II & IV

I have never heard anyone praise this album at all, and I think it is absolutely incredible....pretty much flawless

Probably doesn't help I was born about twelve years post its release...

Thoughts?
"...I said Plum!"
VladDracii
 
Posts: 168
Joined: 23rd Apr 08, 19:13
Location: Eastbourne

Postby earthvs » 20th Oct 08, 22:43

I'd be inclined to disagree that nobody praises it at all - although you are correct that virtually all of the praise is reserved for IV (and in fewer cases II).

I personally think that Presence is their most overlooked and under-rated album.

Perhaps it's because Physical Graffiti is a double album, and therefore harder to absorb in one sitting as a single body of work, that some people might not consider it as one of their best when evaluating Zeppelin's catalogue.

I think the album certainly contains some of their finest moments, but then all of their albums contain some of their finest moments to a greater or lesser degree, including In Through The Outdoor.
Image
"Do you honestly think you can grow wings with those restricting robes?"
earthvs
 
Posts: 54
Joined: 18th Oct 07, 22:13
Location: Shropshire

Postby Ross » 21st Oct 08, 16:52

My favourite's Led Zep 3. It's the perfect album for a sunny day in spring. Try it! And there's not a bad song on there, and I particularly love the acoustic stuff.

They're all fantastic, but I feel the second disc of Physical Graffitti just can't lie up to the first side, which if it had been released on its own, would have been in the all-time classic top ten.
Image
Ross
 
Posts: 407
Joined: 1st Mar 06, 17:28
Location: Leicester UK


Return to The Cloakroom

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest