It's Official....Apparently

Off-topic chat. Items cannot be returned without a ticket.

Postby lob » 23rd Oct 08, 13:21

I find all this bizarre, (time to look away Axl fans) I have never got the attraction. GnR always sounded like a good band spoiled by the lead singers horrible whiny voice to me. Now the more I read about Mr Rose the less I want to know, he seems a genuinely nasty piece of work, I can forgive musicians a fair amount if they are truly gifted but I can't say I have heard anything from him that would make me change my mind.

If I never hear him torturing 'knocking on heavens' door again it will be too soon
Blimey but I am tired
lob
 
Posts: 134
Joined: 11th Aug 06, 15:45
Location: London/Oxford

Postby Jason_scorching_past » 23rd Oct 08, 14:38

lob wrote:I find all this bizarre, (time to look away Axl fans) I have never got the attraction. GnR always sounded like a good band spoiled by the lead singers horrible whiny voice to me. Now the more I read about Mr Rose the less I want to know, he seems a genuinely nasty piece of work, I can forgive musicians a fair amount if they are truly gifted but I can't say I have heard anything from him that would make me change my mind.

If I never hear him torturing 'knocking on heavens' door again it will be too soon


I like Axl's voice myself, and I am not usually a fan of high pitched singers, but his voice is quite versatile. I can see that yes he is egotistical, arrogant and a little bit mental but he makes for a great character to have in Rock.

I loved GNR back during the Illusion days and whilst I don't think much of the band today calling themselves GNR I am still interested in the album cos Axl Rose has written some great rock songs in his lifetime.

I don't know many other bands that sound like GNR on those Illusion albums with the diversity of influences producing some excellent songs, stuff like Estranged, Breakdown, Locomotive etc I still love today.

I can imagine the reviews for this album will be negative because of the years it's taken to be made but I am definitely interested to hear what it sounds like.
Jason_scorching_past
 
Posts: 263
Joined: 20th Jul 08, 20:50

Postby blackdeathcrew » 23rd Oct 08, 17:06

Well, I love the song, and all the other leaked ones too, so I'll definately be getting my Cd on the day of release.
And to all those that say "it's not real GNR, coz there's no slash or duff in it" what about all the other great bands that have lineup changes and still go on to great things too?? (the wildhearts being one of them for example) Just because the lineup changes doesn't mean that they're gonna be crap. Axl, love him or hate him, is an iconic frontman - just listen to scott weiland trying to imitate classic GNR songs - he sounds awful compared to axl in my opinion
blackdeathcrew
 
Posts: 578
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 13:30
Location: Worcestershire

Postby Sarc » 23rd Oct 08, 17:21

blackdeathcrew wrote: And to all those that say "it's not real GNR, coz there's no slash or duff in it" what about all the other great bands that have lineup changes and still go on to great things too?? (the wildhearts being one of them for example) Just because the lineup changes doesn't mean that they're gonna be crap.


That was going to be my next point of argument, cheers fella, saved me from doing it.
Did you just say "Pig Flute"?

http://www.amiatwat.com

Please welcome a new kind of Mod
Sarc
 
Posts: 1934
Joined: 25th Apr 07, 22:27
Location: Brighton

Postby Jason_scorching_past » 23rd Oct 08, 23:14

Sarc wrote:
blackdeathcrew wrote: And to all those that say "it's not real GNR, coz there's no slash or duff in it" what about all the other great bands that have lineup changes and still go on to great things too?? (the wildhearts being one of them for example) Just because the lineup changes doesn't mean that they're gonna be crap.


That was going to be my next point of argument, cheers fella, saved me from doing it.


I guess that all depends on what you consider makes a band a band, is it simply playing the songs or the lead singer staying in the band? I think people say that about Guns N Roses because as huge a star as Axl Rose was, the others had a big role to play in their popularity, the writing and their performances. Izzy and Slash for sure, I mean Slash is easily as famous as Axl Rose cos he was so integral to the band.

With the WIldhearts up until recently it was 99% (100%?) Ginger writing everything and singing on everything so as much as the line-up changes effect the sound to an extent the real thing The WIldhearts has been about for me is Ginger's songwriting.

I think with GNR the dynamic needs to at least include Axl and Slash. For The WIldhearts CJ and Ginger and that is more down to their vocal interplay, Cj sounds the best with Ginger out of all the guitarists IMO.
Jason_scorching_past
 
Posts: 263
Joined: 20th Jul 08, 20:50

Postby Andy » 24th Oct 08, 12:46

There was a full page advert in today's The Sun for the new album.
Andy
 
Posts: 350
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 23:26
Location: Middlesbrough

Postby Sarc » 24th Oct 08, 12:51

Fuck, best get my arse firmed up then, it's looking more and more likley it'll be getting an airing soon.
Did you just say "Pig Flute"?

http://www.amiatwat.com

Please welcome a new kind of Mod
Sarc
 
Posts: 1934
Joined: 25th Apr 07, 22:27
Location: Brighton

Postby nig1012 » 24th Oct 08, 12:58

Sarc wrote:Fuck, best get my arse firmed up then, it's looking more and more likley it'll be getting an airing soon.


try lunges to tone the thighs up as well dude you don't want a tight arse and saggy thighs
is your silence making you lonely?
or is your lonliness making you silent?
nig1012
 
Posts: 877
Joined: 30th Mar 06, 19:16
Location: crewe

Postby blackdeathcrew » 24th Oct 08, 16:59

Image
Image
blackdeathcrew
 
Posts: 578
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 13:30
Location: Worcestershire

Postby Velvet Presley » 25th Oct 08, 04:13

vickyp wrote:We shall just have to wait and see. I'm not getting my hopes up though. I'd like to be pleasantly surprised but we shall see.

Anyway, I see your weird intro to 'Chinese Democracy' and I raise you the intro to Ladytron by Roxy Music.


...and I propose Owner Of A Lonely Heart.

Not a huge GnR far to be honest but I'm looking forward to it - I really like the single, and I'll reserve judgement on the 'new' GnR entirely until I hear the record, I think.
Velvet Presley
 
Posts: 214
Joined: 2nd May 07, 12:00
Location: Edinburgh via Newcastle

Postby EvilElvis » 26th Oct 08, 19:37

Andy wrote:There was a full page advert in today's The Sun for the new album.


Image
EvilElvis
 
Posts: 190
Joined: 19th Feb 06, 13:42
Location: Halfway Up The Downs

Postby Andy » 26th Oct 08, 20:47

Thats the one. Cheers. :)
Andy
 
Posts: 350
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 23:26
Location: Middlesbrough

Postby Soundog » 28th Oct 08, 12:33

That album cover looks unbelievably cheap for such an expensive record. Anyway, I'm looking forward to it - 'Better' is a really cool song (despite the guitar extravaganza), and I hope the finished versions all shine that extra bit brighter compared to the leaked versions.
Soundog
 
Posts: 160
Joined: 29th Mar 07, 09:43
Location: Germany

Postby geordierussell » 28th Oct 08, 15:38

OH DEAR!!!!!!!

----------------
"We wanted to give you an update on the status of your Amazon order. Unfortunately, the release date for the item(s) listed below was changed by the supplier, and we need to provide you with a new estimated delivery date based on the new release date:"

Guns N' Roses "Chinese Democracy" [Audio CD] Estimated arrival date: 01/12/08 - 06/12/08
----------------
geordierussell
 
Posts: 1231
Joined: 9th Mar 06, 18:59
Location: chesterfield

Postby nig1012 » 28th Oct 08, 16:51

geordierussell wrote:OH DEAR!!!!!!!

----------------
"We wanted to give you an update on the status of your Amazon order. Unfortunately, the release date for the item(s) listed below was changed by the supplier, and we need to provide you with a new estimated delivery date based on the new release date:"

Guns N' Roses "Chinese Democracy" [Audio CD] Estimated arrival date: 01/12/08 - 06/12/08
----------------


come on you can't tell me you're surprised by that :lol:
is your silence making you lonely?
or is your lonliness making you silent?
nig1012
 
Posts: 877
Joined: 30th Mar 06, 19:16
Location: crewe

PreviousNext

Return to The Cloakroom

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 10 guests