Metallica vs. The Wildhearts

Off-topic chat. Items cannot be returned without a ticket.

Postby Ross » 30th Jul 07, 10:25

I always thought Cold Patootie Tango sounded like Paradise Lost.

Metallica have always been one of my favourites. And It really makes me laugh to see people still say they "cashed in" or "sold out" with the Black album. One of the things I love about them is that they do whatever they want, and whatever they're feeling at the time, which you have to respect. I'm fairly rare in loving both of the Load albums as much as their early stuff, and I really like St Anger, although it could do with quite a bit of trimming and certain songs (purify) shouldn't have made it past the demo stage.

The thing I always liked was the riffing, the almost symphonic parts of some of the Justice and MoP epics, plus their anger and attitude. Still, seeing them in a live situation is the way to see them and even thinking about that "secret" show at Donington 2003 in the tent still stands the hairs up on the back of my neck. Few bands can do that, and Metallica are one of them. The Wildhearts are another when they hit their stride, but they've always been less "serious" to me than Metallica.
Image
Ross
 
Posts: 407
Joined: 1st Mar 06, 17:28
Location: Leicester UK

Postby davejnick » 30th Jul 07, 19:09

Load, I like. Reload, I think I've listened to twice. And the second time was to make sure my ears weren't lying to me the first time. As for St Anger, I've never listened to that album all the way through, and I have no intention of ever doing so, because what I have heard is fucking horrendous. I even tried to give it away once but nobody I offered it to even wanted a free copy.

It's not cos they "sold out" though. Just cos they're shit albums.
How dare you!
davejnick
 
Posts: 527
Joined: 6th Mar 06, 23:14
Location: The Steel City

Postby SteveP » 30th Jul 07, 22:00

For me, the bloody snare on St Anger pisses me off big time, too light, too tinny.

Actually, I think St Anger was just an exercise in showing the fans and the world that they could still play fast (and heavy to a certain extent), and to be honest, I think it failed, the songs lackd depth, and I feel that their hearts just weren't in it.

As much as some Wildhearts songs don't work sometimes (as verified by other readers of this forums' views on Coupled With), they always seem to have been written and performed with the utmost enthusiasm and feeling, as if it were the last song they were ever to write.
Fr that reason, that's why I have to go for the Wildhearts , whereas Metallica are just one huge rolling money making machine now
Wise UP.....Wise Out

Professional dwarf arsehole
SteveP
 
Posts: 654
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 16:34
Location: Chester le St.

Postby nig1012 » 30th Jul 07, 23:42

plus gingers facial hairs better than james hetfields. that goatee is wild
is your silence making you lonely?
or is your lonliness making you silent?
nig1012
 
Posts: 877
Joined: 30th Mar 06, 19:16
Location: crewe

Postby Andy Santiago » 31st Jul 07, 11:15

seventieslord wrote:
Andy Santiago wrote:At the risk of been totally slated,Metalica should really have fucked right off after 'Master Of Puppets' as everything since has been crap.
Wildhearts for me any day.
Check Gingers speech about Metallica on the 'Grevious Accoustic Behaviour' album! :D


I did note that speech in my original post.

anyways, surely you made a mistake here. And Justice For All would be considered "good" Metallica, along with Kill, Ride, and Puppets, not grouped in as "bad" or "latter day" metallica, with the Black album, load, reload, and St. Anger.

No mistake at all.With the exception of 'Harvester Of Sorrow' 'Justice' was without doubt the begining of the end for Metallica.
Obviously we disagree on this and that is how it will remain.That's one of the best things about music,varying opinions.At least we can agree on the fact that thay are,indeed,crap now!!
"All fucked up and ready to roll"!!
Andy Santiago
 
Posts: 215
Joined: 26th Feb 06, 22:55
Location: Shitsville DN4.

Postby DangerousBeans » 31st Jul 07, 12:10

I'd say The Wildhearts every time.

Kill em All,RTL,Master of Puppets and even the Black album are all brilliant but i've ALWAYS hated And Justice for All.
I won't even start on Load, Reload and St Anger as they are appallingly bad...although Load does have a coupkle of decent tunes on it.

I doubt Metallica would even make my top 10 bands list anymore..although they would make my top 10 live bands one.
DangerousBeans
 
Posts: 287
Joined: 25th Jun 06, 13:15
Location: Ayr

Postby Ross » 31st Jul 07, 16:54

ReLoad has Fixxxer on it, and Where the Wild Things Are. That just about redeems the entire album for me as those two songs are phenomenal. Carpe Diem Baby is also excellent.

Load has Wasting My Hate, Outlaw Torn, Hero of the Day, Bleeding Me, The House That Jack Built, Ronnie (ZZ Top tastic).

There's a five star single album in there. But there is a lot of filler.

St Anger is worth it if you watch the DVD of them performing it. That makes it make sense.
Image
Ross
 
Posts: 407
Joined: 1st Mar 06, 17:28
Location: Leicester UK

Postby markE » 1st Aug 07, 11:27

the difference between the wildhearts and metallibollox is that the wildhearts have songs and lyrics and melody and ideas and.....
why do i have to ignore you to get your attention?
markE
 
Posts: 764
Joined: 18th May 06, 13:53

Postby fluffygrue » 1st Aug 07, 11:31

I'd probably be a much bigger Metallica fan if it wasn't for the really annoying drumming. It's a weird thing to be put off by, but whenever I hear them all I can focus on is Lars' tinny little cymbal noises.
fluffygrue
 
Posts: 528
Joined: 23rd Feb 06, 15:47
Location: Manchester, UK

Postby Stuart Brackpool » 2nd Aug 07, 19:18

SteveP wrote:For me, the bloody snare on St Anger pisses me off big time, too light, too tinny.


I think Metallica and indeed most other thrash bands have suffered from this. For me, the best example of a good all-round drum sound on a thrash (well, sort of...) record is the one achieved by Suicidal Tendencies on their Lights, Camera, Revolution album. Aural pedantry, eh? Can't beat it!

At different times I hear different things with Cold Patootie Tango. Mostly, I like it as a mood piece, setting up the crash into Caprice so I think of it more as an extended intro than a song in its own right. It's a lovely piece, though.
Stuart Brackpool
 
Posts: 173
Joined: 8th Jan 07, 17:18
Location: Halesowen

Postby Arabiandisco » 2nd Aug 07, 22:06

Stuart Brackpool wrote:
SteveP wrote:For me, the bloody snare on St Anger pisses me off big time, too light, too tinny.


I think Metallica and indeed most other thrash bands have suffered from this. For me, the best example of a good all-round drum sound on a thrash (well, sort of...) record is the one achieved by Suicidal Tendencies on their Lights, Camera, Revolution album. Aural pedantry, eh? Can't beat it!

At different times I hear different things with Cold Patootie Tango. Mostly, I like it as a mood piece, setting up the crash into Caprice so I think of it more as an extended intro than a song in its own right. It's a lovely piece, though.


The worst drum sound in the world ever was on '...Justice'.

The Wildhearts are the best band in the history of the world. (Says the guy with a Faith No More username and signature). Metallica don't get into my top 10 - I think the Ramones are the only yanks in that list. Not that I've actually written a list, just thought about it off the top of my head as I'm typing this.

This is my first post by the way, so hello forum. Hopefully the quality of my posts will go up from here. Can't see it going down...
Unleashing the power of mediocrity since 1981
Go 49ers
www.myspace.com/poutband
Arabiandisco
 
Posts: 91
Joined: 2nd Aug 07, 21:57

Postby Steffahoob » 5th Aug 07, 21:22

For me it's The Wildhearts.

Metallica used to be top but that was before I found The Wildhearts. The music is so much more listenable then Tallica's later stuff.

The St Anger drums do my head in, it didn't really bother me to begin with but the more I listened the more it got to me! Most of their albums are good(first 4 are amazing) but yeah...

Both bands are great live though!
Steffahoob
 
Posts: 67
Joined: 12th Jun 07, 22:17
Location: UK

Postby seventieslord » 5th Aug 07, 23:09

Steffahoob wrote:For me it's The Wildhearts.

Metallica used to be top but that was before I found The Wildhearts. The music is so much more listenable then Tallica's later stuff.

The St Anger drums do my head in, it didn't really bother me to begin with but the more I listened the more it got to me! Most of their albums are good(first 4 are amazing) but yeah...

Both bands are great live though!


I think both bands have the talent to do whatever they want, but where Metallica flexes the muscle and shows flashes when they choose, The WIldhearts actually do everything. I've always said that with the Wildhearts, there is something for everybody. You want drug-fueled rock and roll? Got it. You want love songs? Got it. You want hate songs? Got it. You want power ballads? Got it. You want distortion? Got it. You want so much riffing it can be mistaken for prog rock? Got it. You want 2 minute punk songs? Got it. You want 3-4 minute radio singles? Got it. You want happy? Got it. You want sad? Got it. and everything in between.
seventieslord
 
Posts: 437
Joined: 7th Apr 07, 20:45
Location: Canada

Postby Stuart Brackpool » 6th Aug 07, 00:56

seventieslord wrote:I think both bands have the talent to do whatever they want, but where Metallica flexes the muscle and shows flashes when they choose, The WIldhearts actually do everything. I've always said that with the Wildhearts, there is something for everybody. You want drug-fueled rock and roll? Got it. You want love songs? Got it. You want hate songs? Got it. You want power ballads? Got it. You want distortion? Got it. You want so much riffing it can be mistaken for prog rock? Got it. You want 2 minute punk songs? Got it. You want 3-4 minute radio singles? Got it. You want happy? Got it. You want sad? Got it. and everything in between.


Roy Orbison was right, then.

*Sings* 'Anything you want, you got it'.

The first Wildhearts song I heard was Nothing Ever Changes when I was 15. the goosebumps I got while listening to it and the grin that spread across my face told me this was a band I was going to love forever. 15 years later, well, lists are fluid things, but no band has affected me quite so much. Number one and unlikely to drop!
Stuart Brackpool
 
Posts: 173
Joined: 8th Jan 07, 17:18
Location: Halesowen

Postby Steffahoob » 6th Aug 07, 10:25

seventieslord wrote:
I think both bands have the talent to do whatever they want, but where Metallica flexes the muscle and shows flashes when they choose, The WIldhearts actually do everything. I've always said that with the Wildhearts, there is something for everybody. You want drug-fueled rock and roll? Got it. You want love songs? Got it. You want hate songs? Got it. You want power ballads? Got it. You want distortion? Got it. You want so much riffing it can be mistaken for prog rock? Got it. You want 2 minute punk songs? Got it. You want 3-4 minute radio singles? Got it. You want happy? Got it. You want sad? Got it. and everything in between.


That's kinda what I was trying to say! but your way says it better! Lack of sleep is getting to me!
Steffahoob
 
Posts: 67
Joined: 12th Jun 07, 22:17
Location: UK

PreviousNext

Return to The Cloakroom

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests